written by
Oana, Ioana Elena ; Pellegata, Alessandro ; Wang, Chendi
A cure worse than the disease? Exploring the health-economy trade-off during COVID-19 – West European Politics
scritto da
Oana, Ioana Elena ; Pellegata, Alessandro ; Wang, Chendi


Nationwide lockdowns implemented by governments to confront the COVID-19 pandemic came at a high economic price. The article investigates citizens’ evaluation of the trade-off between public health measures and their economic consequences. Using a vignette experiment conducted in June 2020 on 7,500 respondents in seven European countries the article tests whether perceived threats of the health and economic consequences of the COVID-19 pandemic affect citizens’ preferences for strict or mild lockdown measures. Findings show that European citizens tend to prefer strict measures protecting public health despite their damage to the economy. Even individuals more concerned about the pandemic’s economic impact do not prefer milder restrictions. Sociodemographic factors only indirectly affect public preferences, through perceived threats. Additionally, findings show that trust in experts and political orientations matter. These results resonate with previous research showing that public opinion in hard times is likely to be guided by risk perceptions and subjective attitudes.

Supplemental data for this article can be accessed online at: https://doi.org/10.1080/01402382.2021.1933310.

To cite this article:

Ioana-Elena Oana, Alessandro Pellegata & Chendi Wang (2021) A cure worse than the disease? Exploring the health-economy trade-off during COVID-19, West European Politics, DOI: 10.1080/01402382.2021.1933310


#Covid-19 #policy preferences #public opinion #risk perceptions #survey experiment
from the same author:
Bounded solidarity? Experimental evidence on cross-national bonding in the EU during the COVID crisis – European Journal of Political Research
Protest in unlikely times: dynamics of collective mobilization in Europe during the COVID-19 crisis – Journal of European Public Policy
How unified are Europeans’ views on the war in Ukraine?
sullo stesso argomento
Natili, Marcello ; Ronchi, Stefano
Widening double dualisation? Labour market inequalities and national social policy responses in Western Europe during the first wave of the COVID-19 pandemic – Social Policy & Administration
Miró, Joan
Debating fiscal solidarity in the EU: interests, values and identities in the legitimation of the Next Generation EU plan – Journal of European Integration
Ferrara, Federico ; Kriesi, Hanspeter
Crisis pressures and European integration – Journal of European Public Policy
#policy preferences
#public opinion
Wang, Chendi ; Moise, Alexandru D.
A unified autonomous europe? Public opinion of the EU’s foreign and security policy – Journal of European Public Policy
Kyriazi, Anna ; Pellegata, Alessandro ; Ronchi, Stefano
Closer in hard times? The drivers of European solidarity in ‘normal’ and ‘crisis’ times – Comparative European Politics
Ganderson, Joseph
Exiting after Brexit: public perceptions of future European Union member state departures – West European Politics
#risk perceptions
#survey experiment
This project is funded with a Synergy Grant by the European Research Council under Grant Agreement n. 810356. Views and opinions expressed are however those of the author(s) only and do not necessarily reflect those of the European Union or the European Research Council. Neither the European Union nor the granting authority can be held responsible for them.